they were to lie, then information from God would lie a lie, for he has guaranteed the
claim of the Apostles by the manifestation of miracles at their hands. For the miracle is
revealed in place of an utterance from God, "My servant is truthful in all that he
brings from Me." That is, whenever an Apostle comes to his people and says, "I
am an Apostle to you from God," and they say to him, "What is the proof of your
apostolate?" then he shall say, "The splitting of this mountain," for
example. And when they say to him, "Bring what you say," God will split that
mountain at their saying, as a guarantee of the claim of the Apostle to the apostolate.
So, God's splitting the mountain is sent down in place of an utterance from God, " My
servant is truthful in all which he brings to you from Me." And if the Apostle were
lying, this information would be lying. But lying is impossible in the case of God, so
lying on the part of the Apostles is impossible. And whenever lying is denied in them,
Veracity is established.
And as for the proof of the Trustworthiness, that is, their being preserved internally
and externally from forbidden and disliked things; if they were unfaithful in committing
such things, we would be commanded to do the like. But it is impossible that we could be
commanded to do a forbidden or disliked thing, "for God does not command a vile
thing" (Qur. 7, 27). And it is evident that they did nothing except obedience,
whether required or desired, and "permitted" (mubah) things entered among
their actions only to show, whenever they did a "permitted" thing, that it was
allowable (ja'iz.)
And as for the proof of Intelligence, if it were failing in them, how would they be
able to establish an argument against an adversary? But the Qur'an indicates in more than
one place, that they must establish arguments against adversaries. And such establishing
of arguments is only possible with intelligence.
And the proof that fleshly accidents do befall them is that they do not cease to ascend
in their lofty rank; for the occurrence of such accidents is in them for increase in their
lofty rank, for example, and that others may be consoled,
|