150 |
THE
ORIGIN OF ISLAM |
LECT. |
|
perceived unbelief on their part he said, 'Who
are my helpers for God's sake?' The Apostles replied:
'We are God's helpers; we have believed and we testify
that we are Moslems'": and in lxi. v. 14:
"O ye who have believed (i.e. Muhammad's
followers), be helpers of God; as Jesus son of Maryam,
said to the Apostles, 'Who are my helpers for God's
sake?' And the Apostles said: 'We are God's; helpers'.
So part of the Bani Isra'il believed and part disbelieved.
So we assisted those who believed against their enemies,
and they appeared as conquerors." Muhammad
sees in the experience of Jesus a type of his own. Some
of the Bani Isra'il believed and some not. It would
seem to follow logically that the Jews were the unbelieving
part of the Bani Isra'il. The Nasara are the Ansar
Allah (helpers of God), just as the people of Medina
who supported Muhammad were called the Ansar.
It is not necessary to assume that he knew of Christians
so called. He is simply Arabicising the name Nasara.
When these verses were composed it seems evident that
Muhammad had ceased to look with favour upon the Jews,
but still regarded the Nasara as hopeful. How completely
in course of time he swung round from the Jews to the
Christians is shown by v. v. 85: "Thou wilt
find that the most hostile of men towards those who
have believed are the Jews, and the Polytheists, and
the most favourable towards those who have believed
are those who say, 'We are Nasara'. That is because
there are amongst them priests and monks, and because
they are not proud." They are assigned a place
in Paradise. |
|
V |
ATTITUDE
TO CHRISTIANITY |
151 |
|
A less positive attitude is shown in xxii. v. 17
when he details the various classes of men and says:
"God will distinguish on the Resurrection Day
between those who have believed (the Moslems),
those who have 'repented' (the Jews), the
Sabi'in, the Nasara, the Magi, and those who ascribe
partners to God (the Pagan Polytheists)".
The phrase is a common one, equivalent to something
like "the unbelievers will see on the Judgement
Day who has been right". But where exactly the
distinction will fall is not quite clear. My own impression
is that Moslems, Jews, Sabi'in, Nasara, and Magi will,
in Muhammad's opinion, be on one side of the line, and
the idolaters on the other.
But when Muhammad's power began to spread in Arabia
his attitude towards the Christians soon began to cool.
Any real alliance or even peaceful accommodation was
indeed impossible from the first. Muhammad complains
(ii. v. 114) that neither Jews nor Christians will be
satisfied with him until he follows their milla
or type of religion. It was just as impossible for him
to make concessions. I have pointed out that probably
from the first Muhammad contemplated a revived religious
community centring in Mecca. At any rate the political
complexion of his religion did not originate in Medina.
From the time when it became clear to him that prophets
and their followers survived the calamity which they
predicted, and that it would be part of the work of
a prophet, like Moses for instance, to form a people
according to God's law, this entered into his conception.
If we examine carefully his |
|